On being numbed by numbers

(Reading time: 9 minutes)

Halloween is not only about goblins and ghouls. It’s also the starting gun in the sprint to Thanksgiving and Christmas, when charities and social welfare agencies lean into the charitable impulses such holidays inspire. But this also is the season when shorter days and colder nights bring human needs more to the forefront, so there’s a push as well as a pull to the seasonal tugging at heartstrings and wallets.

There are several trusted strategies deployed to support such imploring. One is to tell stories of people in need, suffering because of fate’s fickle finger rather than as a result of personal failings. Another is to highlight the ever-greater cruelty of the grasping Orange Man, laying waste to Medicaid, food stamps and housing subsidies. A third is to cite reams of statistics to summarize not just how bad things have become, but to show how rapidly they’re deteriorating.

And that’s a problem. Most people don’t do numbers so good.

The Blue Ridge Area Food Bank (BRAFB) inadvertently provided proof of this innumeracy a couple of weeks ago, jumping the gun on the charitable-giving season with a Zoom presentation on hunger in Virginia. The Oct.14 session, which drew 77 participants, proceeded with the observation that most people in the food bank industry expected demand to peak in the years immediately after the 2020 Covid pandemic. Instead, food demand has kept growing, year after year, and “we’re very concerned about the wave we see coming,” explained BRAFB chief executive Kari Diener.

To buttress that concern, lots and lots of numbers got tossed around, from poverty stats to SNAP enrollment figures to financial pressure points forcing people to skimp on life’s other essentials to keep from starving to death. The bottom line, however, could be summarized in just one statistic: that 42% of Virginia households face food insecurity, meaning they don’t have enough food to eat or don’t know where their next meal will come from. Forty-two percent is a lot; 3.7 million people.

Well, maybe.

THE PROBLEM WITH NUMBERS, as I’ve written before, is that they seem so damn authoritative. People’s emotions are squishy and changeable, but we all have them and so tend to think we’re experts when it comes to examining or questioning feelings.

Numbers are different: angular, sharp-edged, resistant to interpretation. Or so they seem, never mind the confusion of Boolean algebra allowing 1+1=0 or the profound (and profoundly disturbing) complexities of quantum physics that enable things to simultaneously exist and not exist. Throw a lot of numbers at most people and their critical faculties seize up, unable to question even the most obvious incongruities, either for fear of seeming stupid or simply because they don’t actually see what’s being shown. Numbers are taken at face value in a way that people rarely are.

That’s pretty much what happened with the food bank presentation on hunger, based on a statewide survey conducted this past May by NORC (formerly the National Opinion Research Center) at the University of Chicago. To be fair to the Zoom call’s participants, neither the survey itself nor its methodology were shared on the call, just its interpreted results. To see the actual data one had to visit the website of the Federation of Virginia Food Banks, headquartered in Richmond, which apparently commissioned the survey on behalf of the seven food banks that serve the state. (BRAFB, for example, covers 25 counties in the western end of Virginia.) Yet even that wasn’t very rewarding in terms of getting basic information.

Despite the federation’s website claim that its survey “offers a new level of precision that captures the extent of food insecurity across the state,” a link purporting to explain the survey’s methodology does no such thing. It simply provides a summary of conclusions. The survey’s supposed precision, meanwhile, is encapsulated in a one-page data sheet that in mid-October waved a very noticeable red flag by claiming to have interviewed the same number (560) of respondents in the BRAFB area as in the much more heavily populated Capital Area Food Bank region. Moreover, while the study states that it surveyed a total of 5,621 Virginians, the individual totals for the seven food bank areas at that time added up to just 3,975.

Oct. 14: An unbelievable—literally unbelievable—duplication of numbers.

The identical number of respondents for two greatly disparate food bank areas should have caught the eye of anyone at BRAFB preparing for the Zoom call, but apparently no one looked. Worse yet, a second data row, reporting how many respondents were food insecure, had the same problems: identical numbers of the food insecure (163) in both the BRAFB and Capital Area Food Bank. Meanwhile, the food-insecure total for all seven food banks, 1,474, fell far short of the 2,333 claimed for the state as a whole—yet that’s the number from which 42% food insecurity was computed.

My questions to BRAFB about these inconsistencies resulted in several email exchanges and three different versions of the data. The duplicated numbers were attributed in Richmond to an “administrative error” that, when corrected, increased the number of Capital Area respondents to 2,206 and the number of the Capital Area food-insecure to 535. With that change, the state total for all respondents matched the sum of the seven food bank areas—but even with the Capital Area increase in the number of food-insecure respondents, the total for the seven food banks in that category was still 486 less than the 2,333 claimed statewide.

Oct. 22: An unheralded number change, but without modifying state totals.

Was that a problem? Apparently not in Richmond, which in response to my further questions to BRAFB simply changed the statewide number of food insecure respondents to 1,846. No explanation was provided for the change, which now matched the total of the seven food banks. And no reason—“administrative error” or otherwise—was provided for why this error had occurred in the first place.

Currently: Fudging the numbers, but without changing the calculations that follow.

Here’s the thing, though: these changes have only dug a deeper pit of uncertainty for the food bank’s statistical claims. When the survey initially asserted that 2,333 of its respondents were food insecure, that worked out to 41.5% of its sample pool. Lowering that number to 1,846 drops the percentage of food insecure respondents to a tad less than 33%, yet the data sheet that’s still online clings stubbornly to its claim of 42%. That’s a big discrepancy. Huge, even.

DOES ANY OF THIS MATTER? These are just numbers, after all, and mistakes happen, and . . . and.

It matters for the same reason that it would matter if BRAFB were to present a heart-tugging story of a single unemployed mother suffering from a debilitating illness for whom a local food pantry had meant she could feed her three children, only to find out that the single mother was as healthy as a horse or that she had a cushy job or that the three kids were her neighbor’s, provided as photo-op props. The story’s coloration changes. A third of all respondents is still a lot of people facing food insecurity, but it’s not as dramatic as 42%, so why not go with the better story? Meanwhile, the data sheet that offers “a new level of precision” about hunger in Virginia has 30 more rows of percentages about hunger, both statewide and for each of the seven food bank areas, all of which should now be questioned.

None of this is to suggest there’s anything nefarious going on, or that BRAFB is guilty of deliberate deception. If anything, BRAFB is the unwitting victim of sloppy data manipulation by others, compounded by its own lack of attention to detail. But BRAFB also is a participant in a game of pass-the-buck, serving as a go-between to the Federation of Virginia Food Banks but deflecting questions about data manipulation to NORC, which responded to my inquiries about who prepared the original data sheet by suggesting I contact . . .  the Federation of Virginia Food Banks. Which, to date, has not responded to several inquiries that started more than two weeks ago.

The problem is not only that a potentially powerful message about hunger in Virginia has been undercut by an unexplained butchering of fundamental facts. The wider problem is that local social service agencies keep shooting themselves in the foot with an essentially cavalier approach to numbers generally and to numbers that keep them financially accountable specifically. I’ve written about this before, excoriating SAW Habitat for Humanity for fudging its tax reports in such a way as to obscure a lack of accounting for 12 months of receipts and expenses. And I returned to this problem more recently by questioning the apparent disappearance of more than a million dollars over several years at the Verona Community Food Pantry.

In those cases, too, the response has been to admit to nothing and to stonewall any inquiries. And while BRAFB can sidestep questions about the data it presented mid-October by asserting that it was simply a conduit for others, it has been just as quick to take a hands-off approach to the Verona food pantry’s accounting problems by noting that the food bank and the food pantry are separate legal entities. That’s true as far as it goes, but it obscures the legal relationship between the two organizations that defines financial terms, operational responsibilities and compliance requirements.

At a most fundamental level, all these agencies are part of a social welfare ecosystem that is highly dependent on public support and public trust. Trust is built on transparency and accountability, which in turn depend on accurately presenting facts and figures so that the public understands what’s going on. Lose that trust in one area, whether because of guile, heedlessness or just telling a story too well, and you weaken the entire structure.

A million-dollar food pantry mystery

(Reading time: 8 minutes)

Private social service agencies—the kind that are fueled by donor dollars, government grants and volunteer labor—often share a dirty little secret that the broader public rarely learns about: they get captured by the people who run them. Paid (usually poorly) or unpaid, those who give their time, labor and waking thoughts to running an organization that exists to help others often start identifying more with the organization than with the public it serves, then eventually view the organization as an extension of themselves.

When that happens, be it at a local volunteer fire department, food pantry or shelter, people can become possessive and territorial. Questions about an organization’s operations or bookkeeping are interpreted as challenges of personal integrity. “Doing good” outweighs “doing right,” leading to rationalizing of all kinds of questionable behavior.

Bad things follow.

Certainly we’ve seen examples of this dynamic locally. The erstwhile local United Way is the poster child for charitable organizations going astray, permanently closing its doors a couple of years ago because of misfeasance. The SAW Habitat for Humanity came close to meeting the same fate and is still not making a clean breast of things, refusing to account for 12 months of revenues and expenses over the past few years. Now it appears the Verona Community Food Pantry may be joining those ranks—and it couldn’t be at a worse time.

THANKS TO A LETHAL combination of steadily rising prices and the Trump administration’s war on social benefits of all kinds, one of the agriculturally most productive countries in the world is being ravaged by growing food insecurity. That means food pantries and the food banks that support them have seldom been as critically important to community welfare.

Just how bad are things getting? According to the recently released results of a statewide survey commissioned by the Federation of Virginia Food Banks and the Virginia Department of Social Services, more than half (51%) of Virginia families with children are food insecure. That compares with the 42% of Virginians who reported they were food insecure in last year’s U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) annual hunger survey, a figure so stark that the USDA thereafter ended decades of data collection on the subject.

(The USDA announced the survey’s termination last September by explaining that “these redundant, costly, politicized, and extraneous studies do nothing more than fear monger.” Past studies were “initially created by the Clinton administration as a means to support the increase of SNAP [food stamps] eligibility and benefit allotments,” but “failed to present anything more than subjective, liberal fodder.” Who knew that facts leaned left, or that collecting them would result in fear mongering?)

Ironically, “food insecurity” used to be an official USDA term. It refers to people who don’t have enough to eat and don’t know where their next meal will come from, and has grown in tandem with cuts in social benefits. More than 100,000 Virginians have lost their SNAP benefits over the past year, and more losses are expected in the year ahead, making food pantries an increasingly critical lifeline for growing numbers of local residents.

Food pantries, which in our region coordinate their efforts through the Blue Ridge Area Food Bank, freely redistribute food donated by supermarkets, bakeries, local farmers and other sources, including hunters who contribute game. They also distribute surplus USDA food (think cheese, but also much more), whose recipients must qualify under federal poverty income guidelines. But while the food itself is free, gathering, storing and distributing it is not. There are expenses. How much and how that’s paid is where things can get dicey.

The Verona Community Food Pantry, which has been operating rent-free out of an Augusta County-owned building in Verona since 2006, presents itself as a low-overhead example of a lean operation. Boasting that it has an all-volunteer operation with no payroll and no paid outside contractors, it rolls along year after year on not much more than $50,000 in annual expenses for such basics as insurance, postage, and truck gas and repairs. On that threadbare budget it manages to distribute more than a million pounds of food each year, supplying hundreds of local residents with groceries it calculates are worth an estimated $250 to $300 per visit. Again, keep in mind: most of that food has been donated.

In addition to food, and like all other pantries, the Verona pantry also pulls in cash gifts and donations to fund its operations, and raises additional money through yard sales, concerts and other fund-raisers. And while a chunk of that money goes to the Blue Ridge Area Food Bank (BRAFB) to purchase sharply discounted food, such as meat, that is less available from the usual sources, such spending is only a fraction of the cash that the pantry brings in each year.

Specifically, as reported in the pantry’s federal 990 tax filings, those cash contributions amounted to $858,092 in 2024, $493,576 in 2023, $520,140 in 2022 and $501,041 in 2021. That adds up a four-year total of $2.4 million, following a huge surge of post-pandemic support for all kinds of charitable organizations. Of that $2.4 million, $417,624 went to food bank purchases and another $161,293 for those lean operating expenses.

The other $1.8 million?  Good question.

Some of it—a hefty amount, actually—has been squirreled away, although to what purpose is unclear. Excess revenue in the pantry’s early years was used for much needed capital improvements, including freezers, a truck, a forklift and bathrooms at the warehouse, but such spending has become infrequent this decade. The cash instead has been piling up, reaching $758,146 at the end of 2024—enough to generate nearly $29,000 in investment income in just that one year. Putting aside the question of why the pantry needs cash reserves of 15 times its annual operating expenses, that still leaves more than a million dollars unaccounted for. Where did it go?

The pantry’s managers, alas, are not saying.

NON-PROFIT 501(c)3s like the Verona Community Food Pantry can be notoriously opaque—until red flags start popping up. Maybe especially when red flags pop up.

One such flag may get waved by governing board members jumping ship, which may be nothing more than a consequence of otherwise benign organizational changes or of multiple personal reasons coinciding. But several near-simultaneous resignations also may signal something more troubling—and few things are more troubling to board members than financial impropriety, forcing them to balance their fiduciary duties against a desire not to harm the reputation of an organization whose mission they’ve embraced. One way out of that dilemma is to just walk away.

 It’s noteworthy, therefore, that some unknown number of the Verona pantry’s board members reportedly have let it be known they’re resigning, although how many and for what reasons has not been made public.

A second red flag may appear when information about an organization dries up. For example, the most recent post on the pantry’s Facebook page, which previously had been updated on a regular basis, was in March. Its federal 990 tax form for 2025, which had a filing deadline in May, is nowhere to be seen, which means the pantry’s most recent publicly available financial information is more than 20 months old. (Although this isn’t the first time the pantry missed a filing: it apparently also didn’t file for 2015.) And the pantry is on thin ice with the State Corporation Commission, where its corporate status is “pending inactive” because “annual registration fee past due and/or penalties unpaid and annual report past due—not in good standing.”

 It’s possible these are mere paperwork oversights because the pantry has a new board president, but its executive director, Ike Moore, has been at the helm since 2017.

But a third and most damning red flag is run up the pole when an organization stonewalls reasonable inquiries. Asked about people quitting the board, former president Cecil Wright—the last board president to have his name appear on a form 990—confirmed that resignations are expected but that as of last week no letters of resignation had been received. Who those members might be or why they are quitting, he would not say. Nor would he provide any contact information for anyone in the pantry’s leadership. Meanwhile, several attempts over the past week to get answers to a detailed set of emailed questions, sent to Moore and to the new board president, Chris Terrell, went unanswered, despite a phoned assurance from Terrell that he would do so.

That’s altogether too many red flags, and all the more so in the context of financials that don’t add up.

The Blue Ridge Area Food Bank, although it’s an entirely separate organization, has some oversight of its constituent pantries. But Robin Swecker, BRAFB’s “partner engagement manager,” downplays any problems at the Verona pantry, describing them as merely a “bump in the road” that “has been resolved for now.” The nature of that bump? “It was mostly growing pains” she wrote in an email, of an organization that has been around for 20 years.

Follow-up questions about that assessment also went unanswered.