The harsh season of the Christ child

(Reading time: 6 minutes)

Tired yet of hearing about El Niño? Better get used to it, because it’s only going to get more mentions in the weeks ahead.

The ominous map above, in which the yellow ‘X’ marks our spot, is courtesy of the European Space Agency (ESA), which increasingly is being consulted by big business as a more reliable source than our gutted U.S. forecasting agencies. It was released within the past week, and while there’s invariably a lot of scientific guesswork involved in looking at weather patterns two to five months in the future, the bigger trend it’s affirming is that our neck of the woods can expect a colder and snowier winter than “normal.” El Niño is largely to blame for that, including its destabilizing effect on the Polar Vortex, another weather phenomenon about which we’ll be hearing a lot more.

What makes this topical is that our local emergency cold weather shelter, operated by the Waynesboro Area Refuge Ministry (WARM), will open for the new season Nov. 23—which is to say, a little more than a week from now, or just after the first extended spell of subfreezing overnight temperatures.  Moving a week at a time from one church to another—with a one-week detour to Augusta Expo—throughout the Staunton-Augusta-Waynesboro (SAW) area, the shelter will provide overnight cots and meals for up to 50 local residents who otherwise would be huddling for warmth in doorways, cars or nylon tents. The WARM program will run through the end of March.

Anyone living locally will remember the state of emergency that was declared in Staunton this past January, when the entire region was gripped by a storm that started as a snowfall and ended as an icy straitjacket. Circumstances were so dire that Staunton mayor Michele Edwards convened an emergency meeting of local providers to come up with a plan for housing those who couldn’t be accommodated by WARM, with Central United Methodist Church filling the gap for almost two weeks. Ironically, the deep freeze was so bad that the local Point in Time (PIT) count, an annual mid-winter census of homeless people, didn’t even attempt to locate homeless people not already in a shelter. That resulted in a laughably lower headcount than in 2025.

With the ESA predicting an additional 8 to 10 inches of snow above the norm for us this winter, the odds of another emergency with a disparate impact on the homeless are daunting. But the number of shelter options has not increased, which means there’s still a shortage of 70 to 90 beds in our area even with WARM’s seasonal participation. We also still don’t have a warming shelter in which homeless people can take refuge during the day, which for WARM’s clients starts at 7 a.m., when they are required to leave their overnight quarters. And we have limited transportation available for those who need to reach a cold weather shelter that moves to a new location every Monday, across a geographic  expanse stretching from Lyndhurst to Mt. Sidney.

You might think that last January would have been a wakeup call to local officials and service agencies, a call to arms to avert a possible tragedy, but you’d be wrong. Any momentum for addressing the root causes of homelessness—most prominent among them a lack of sufficient affordable housing—has steadily dribbled away. The turgid Staunton Housing Commission, for example, a substantial part of its work preempted by state legislation that mandates some of the initiatives it was just beginning to contemplate, went four months between its two most recent meetings and won’t meet again until February. That’s not the kind of eager restlessness needed to meet a challenge that is not sitting still.

Then there’s the amorphous SAW Housing group, an outgrowth of two enthusiastically attended housing conferences a couple of years ago that has dwindled in size and energy ever since, and now likewise convenes just every three to four months. Its website is untended and outdated—there is no mention, for example, of the group’s next “Lunch ’n’ Learn” program, scheduled for this coming Wednesday at Augusta Expo. There is no formal structure, so no one to hold accountable—indeed, no leadership names or contact information are anywhere to be found. And the minutes for the group’s most recent meeting, Oct. 7, could have been describing a year-old discussion with their description of “defining gaps in the local housing landscape,” as though that remains a mystery.

The debilitating effect of such lassitude is hard to overstate. A few weeks ago I received an email from one of my readers that read, in part: “I have been in the saw housing group for over a year. I’m irritated by having meetings and having nothing be done. I’m not sure how to help. . . . I joined the housing group hoping to meet others who could invest or change zoning to have manufactured homes or to get grants. Anything to help, but it just has been a lesson in futility.”

Meanwhile, WARM itself is struggling, unable to attract a qualified applicant to become executive director, following Alec Gunn’s health-related resignation several months ago. And Staunton city council, despite an unexpected abundance of excess revenues over the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30—8% over budget from local sales tax, nearly 7% over budget from its meals tax and 14% over budget from its lodging tax—never once suggested applying the $1.1 million windfall to addressing the city’s homelessness issues. Having city visitors help pay for school improvements by raising the sales tax was a winning political slogan, but apparently not winning enough when applied to people living in the streets.

(If the needs of kids are an effective way of tugging at heart/purse strings, perhaps city leaders should pay attention to the past week’s release of a report by the SchoolHouse Connection on infant and toddler homelessness. Based on U.S. Census data from 2023-2024, the group concluded that more than 513,000 U.S. children experienced homelessness from birth though age three, or roughly one in 29. More than 7,000 of those children were in Virginia.)

El Niño is a shortened form of El Niño de Navidad, which translates as “the Christ child” because of the season in which it reaches maximum strength. That, too, is ironic, if unhappily so.

A cry from the heart goes unheard

(Reading time: 5 minutes)

“No Place to Grow Old,” a cri de cœur on behalf of society’s most vulnerable members, was screened Thursday night at Trinity Episcopal Church in downtown Staunton. For all the ears, eyes and hearts it reached, it may as well have been screamed into a well or from a wind-whipped cliff. No more than a score of people showed up, at least half of whom already work locally with the homeless—which is to say, this was a gospel being preached to the already converted.

What a sadly lost opportunity that was.

“No Place to Grow Old,” although filmed in Portland, has been shown hundreds of times across the U.S. in school auditoriums, church basements, service organization halls—wherever a handful of people touched by its portrayal can cobble together a screening. The story it tells is not particular to Oregon but is replicated in one community after another, including ours. Its main protagonists are uniquely distinctive voices that nevertheless describe an increasingly universal experience, providing an unflinching look at the stark realities of being old and homeless in a society that prefers not to see its failures in such raw close-up.

The biggest difference in homelessness between Portland and Staunton? The tents in Portland are right out there on the sidewalks. Here they’re hidden away, tucked into overgrown lots behind shopping centers, allowing us to maintain the fiction that this really isn’t that big a problem.

To dispel that myth, here are some of the numbers that came out of the after-movie panel discussion on Thursday. Within the SAW region of Staunton, Augusta County and Waynesboro, at least 250 homeless people have been counted in the annual census known as the Point in Time (PIT) count, and the people doing the counting agree this is an undercount. Three years ago, Valley Supportive Housing—which provides subsidized housing to local residents with a mental illness, intellectual disability or substance abuse issues—had a waiting list of 15 to 20. Today, that list has grown to 107.

Valley Mission, the only local emergency shelter for the general population, served 649 people in 2016 but only 247 in 2025—not because demand has gone down, but because of a sharp decrease in local affordable housing for people in the shelter to move into, which means the shelter’s revolving door is turning more and more slowly, and fewer people who need it can get in. The Mission, too, has a waiting list, of approximately 100. Ironically, 20 of the homeless shelter’s clients are earning a paycheck but can’t find an apartment they can afford, contributing to the logjam.

While Valley Supportive Housing historically has served people who are psychologically or mentally fragile, both that population and the homeless generally become even more vulnerable as they get older. People who are already homeless age much more rapidly than their housed counterparts, with people in their 50s having the bodies of someone 20 or more years older. Roughly 35% of the Mission’s residents are at least 55, and with each passing year that percentage grows. Meanwhile, the number of freshly minted homeless old people also is growing, as people who managed to keep a roof over their heads for most of their lives get squeezed out of their homes by rising rents, illness, or other life circumstances that outstrip their reserves.

Nationally, single adults over 50 now make up half of the homeless population.

In crude economic terms, this is a huge social burden. Valley Supportive Housing, for example, reports that its residents have one-third the annual number of psychiatric crises they had suffered before getting into a home, resulting in far fewer emergency room visits—at more than $2,200 a pop—arrests or mental hospital commitments. With jail costs of $120 a day and a single day at a mental hospital coming in at $700, the savings in taxpayer dollars due to the organization’s activities run into six and seven figures.

But those are just numbers, and while data are important to understand the full extent of a problem, it’s the personal stories told in “No Place to Grow Old” that give it depth and emotional resonance. These are people who have or had parents and children, who held responsible jobs and looked after other people, who had and have dreams and passions and fears. They’re not lazy or parasites or too stupid to do better. They’re people who may have been your neighbors or the clerk who helped you at a store down the street or a local handyman or groundskeeper, but who, through a turn of bad luck—a divorce, a death in the family, a broken hip—have been ejected from one life and into another, much less privileged one.

The problem with listening to these stories and to looking into the eyes of those who tell them is that once you’ve done that, it’s so much harder to carry on with your normal life without doing something in response. Some things are hard to unsee—and shouldn’t be. But that’s exactly why “No Place to Grow Old” should be seen more widely, and especially by those who might be able to do something in response: our city council members, who establish the city’s priorities. City planners and managers who will be preparing the next municipal budget. The members of our newly formed housing commission, who are charged with planning for the city’s housing needs. Planning board commissioners and members of the Economic Development Authority and the guiding lights behind the heretofore mute Valley Program for Aging Services.

Local clergy, who should be thundering about the least among us from their pulpits.

All these people, as well as the public at large, do have one more—but just one more—chance to see this film, which will be shown next Sunday (Oct. 25) at 3 p.m. in the fellowship hall of Central United Methodist Church, also in downtown Staunton. Come and bear witness.

The “No Place to Grow Old” trailer can be seen here.

In Staunton, too, no place to grow old

(Reading time: 12 minutes)

There aren’t a lot of U.S. tax dollars coming into Staunton these days, and less all the time, thanks to—well, you know. So the little bit that does trickle in should be scrupulously measured and dispensed where it can do the most good, and that includes the approximately $323,000 that comes our way each year via the federal Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program. That’s the program whose No. 1 “overarching objective” is to “provide decent affordable housing.”

It’s therefore perplexing to read, in Staunton’s annual CBDG action plan for 2026, that the Valley Program for Aging Services (VPAS) was one of eight local social service agencies that were consulted by the city when it assessed how that money should be spread around. Specifically, VPAS was sought out because of its presumed understanding of “non-homeless special needs” of the elderly, which, fair enough. But according to the action plan, VPAS also was consulted for a “housing needs assessment,” which is nonsense.

VPAS does many good things for local residents who are getting on in years, including Meals on Wheels to deliver food and a transportation program enabling non-driving seniors to keep medical and other appointments. (Each of those programs stands to get a modest CDBG grant.) But VPAS has absolutely nothing to do with either assessing or meeting anyone’s housing needs. As I wrote in February, the organization’s strategic plan for 2025-2027—optimistically headlined “Charting a New Course”—never once mentions housing, and executive director Beth Bland, citing limited resources, said that isn’t about to change. Indeed, she added, “We are not prepared to be, nor would it be appropriate for us, to take the lead on this issue.”

City planners clearly don’t understand that, their misrepresentation of VPAS’s expertise attesting to the compartmentalization of critical information that can occur even in as small a community as Staunton. Not that the assumption was unreasonable. VPAS is one of more than 600 Area Agencies on Aging across the country that were established decades ago by Congress under the Older Americans Act, and given its broad mandate to serve the needs of older Americans, it’s not far-fetched to think that those needs would include housing.

That it doesn’t, says something about the Older Americans Act. That city planners don’t know that says something about Staunton.

WHILE MOST PEOPLE are aware of, if not knowledgeable about, Medicaid and Medicare, which were passed at the same time as the Older Americans Act, the latter has had a much lower profile. To some extent that may be indicative of a general American attitude toward old people, perhaps the most easily overlooked demographic segment of our society. Much is made (appropriately) of the high cost of day care and the burden it places on working families. Public schools claim a significant chunk of every locality’s taxes and of its electoral attention. Affordable housing for the working class is a hot topic, as are labor force participation, unemployment rates and other issues that affect people well into middle age.

But old people tend to fade into the background. They ask less of society, and society expects less from them. Historically, most have owned their homes after decades of paying off their mortgages. Others live in housing complexes designed specifically for the elderly, with varying degrees of supportive care. Either way, all those people tend to disappear from view, and the kinds of services that the Older Americans Act underwrites have similarly limited visibility in the wider community. In some ways, therefore, the more successful the Older Americans Act and its programs have been, the more invisible its target population has become.

Yet times change. The Older Americans Act is supposed to be reauthorized by Congress every four years but was last reupped in 2020, so it’s already two years overdue. Although the Senate got around to passing a reauthorization bill this past July, the House of Representatives went home without following suit, leaving a zombie in its wake: a service organization sustained by annual appropriations (at least so far), but unable to update its programs in response to changing needs.

And that’s the other half of the equation: those needs are not only changing, but changing at a growing clip as the U.S. population ages. Back in 1965, and for most of the decades since, the act’s focus has been on helping older Americans age in place, through case management services, Medicare counseling, respite and transportation services, and health and wellness programs. Housing was hardly on anyone’s radar. But between 2013 and 2023 the number of people 65 or older renting their homes grew nearly 30%, making them increasingly vulnerable to market forces. Some of that increase is due simply to more people getting older, but some of it is due to people selling their homes as they age.

Today, one in five older adults is a renter, and of that number half are cost-burdened, meaning they spend more than 30% of their income on rent. But whether they’re renting or living in their own home, elderly people face several challenges that make their continued independence problematic. Trips and falls, more likely if a home hasn’t had the elder equivalent of toddler-proofing, are the leading cause of injuries among those 65 and older, sometimes—as with a fractured hip—with devastating consequences. Failing memories can make management of personal finances, including payment of rent or mortgage and utility bills, a game of Russian roulette.  And married couples inevitably become widows or widowers, which further isolates the survivors even as they themselves grow more vulnerable.

No surprise, then, that old people can be just a physical or financial stumble away from becoming homeless.  Adults 55 and older now comprise 20% of the homeless population, with two of every five older adults experiencing their first episode of homelessness after the age of 50. This is a population, in other words, of people who for most of their adult lives were mostly self-sufficient contributing members of society but suddenly found themselves unable to care for their basic needs. Add their numbers to the cohort of long-term homeless people who are aging into senior citizen status and you have what Ann Oliva, chief executive of the National Alliance to End Homelessness, describes as “the fastest growing and least visible trend in homelessness.”

A piece of federal legislation that was crafted to help senior citizens “age in place” is ill-equipped to help them when that place is gone. But if the Older Americans Act is frozen by Congressional inaction, rendered incapable of adapting to changing circumstances, what—or who—will pick up the slack?

FAILURE TO RECOGNIZE the growing mismatch between the housing needs of its oldest residents and the resources available to them through VPAS means, in some respects, that Staunton is off the hook. From a cynic’s perspective, the existence of a federally- and state-funded organization to take care of the needs of the elderly means one less worry for budget-constrained municipal leaders. And if VPAS doesn’t accept a role of housing advocate for the elderly, as Beth Bland’s comment underscores, city leaders can’t be held accountable for their oversight.

But the grim reality is that whatever the national trends may be, they are more pronounced here in the Queen City. Not only does Staunton have a higher percentage of old people than is true nationally, but it also has a slightly higher poverty rate, a higher proportion of rental housing and a higher percentage of old people living alone. One obvious inference is that the city has a higher than national average of elderly people who either already are or are in danger of becoming homeless, a problem made more acute by the city’s lack of social services specifically targeting that population.

Yet one of the biggest obstacles to Staunton successfully addressing the problem of elderly homelessness is its lack of hard data—you can’t fix something you can’t document as broken. The evidence of Staunton’s housing needs is often similar to the evidence for planets circling stars many light years away, deduced from slight spectral shifts but always portrayed in an artist’s rendering because no one’s actually seen such a thing.

Local efforts to enumerate the homeless have been halting and piecemeal. The usual measuring stick nationally, as well as locally, is a one-night census in January known as the Point in Time (PIT) count, which is widely criticized for its limited scope—made even more so this year by an extreme winter storm that limited the count to people already in shelters. Even with that limitation, however, this year’s PIT count identified 45 homeless people 55 and older, or 31% of the local tally and up from 39 in 2025. There’s no telling how many people sleeping in their cars, in a tent or on a Good Samaritan’s couch went uncounted. Meanwhile, a separate but suggestive finding was that 39% of those identified by the PIT count reported they were homeless for the first time.

Nevertheless, the implication of both such limited data and of broader national trends is that we face a growing storm, one made more threatening by the federal government’s retreat from the promises it made decades ago. That doesn’t mean there’s nothing we can do, however—as long as we face up to the situation, and provided also that we acknowledge that doing anything will require spending local dollars. The federal cavalry simply is not coming, and state support is questionable, at best.

Consider San Diego County, for example, which created a shallow rental subsidy program in 2023 to provide rental assistance to low-income adults 55 and older who were at risk of eviction. Initially set up as a pilot program, the approach is now entering its third cycle and is being replicated elsewhere. “Our biggest aha! moment was, for those who are experiencing housing insecurity, a simple $300 to $500 a month of rental assistance would have kept them housed,” Melinda Forstey, president and CEO of Serving Seniors, told a Shelterforce reporter. “If you compare that to some estimates where it can be $50,000 a year for one individual experiencing homelessness, it’s not only the ethical thing to do, it’s clearly the more economic thing to do as well.”

Assuming something similar were undertaken in Staunton, that would mean an outlay of $7,200 could keep someone in his or her home for 18 months instead of living on the street, hopefully long enough to get back on their feet. In any rational universe, that’s a no-brainer.

If homelessness is not prevented, swift intervention to help the elderly becomes more critical than for any group other than the very young. Living on the street exacerbates every aspect of aging. People stop getting older on a human schedule, their life spans instead whittled away in giant gulps—a process that anyone working with local homeless people has observed. Federal estimates are that a 50-year-old homeless person has the health profile of a 70- to 80-year-old; 70% of that population has visited an emergency room within the last year, compared to 19% of all older adults nationally.

Those kinds of statistics underscore the urgency of providing shelter space that can quickly meet the more specialized needs of old people, such as Denver’s push to create emergency shelters that are age restricted to those 55 or older. Locally, however, the only homeless shelter is the Mission, which has a waiting list but which in any case is incompatible with the needs of people too old to clamber into bunk beds, who have special dietary needs because of their age, or who feel threatened by a younger, sometimes predatory population. And while there are limited—and much needed—shelter spaces elsewhere in our area for abused women, there has been no comparable recognition of the emergency shelter needs of this equally vulnerable group.     

Where would the money come from to provide such a shelter? That’s a fair question, but one without an answer until the social agencies closest to the problem start ringing the alarm bell. That could include the Mission itself, which is sitting on a nest egg that could make a significant dent in creating a new facility. It definitely should include VPAS, which Staunton has already declared is responsible for assessing the housing needs of the elderly. It also could include the Valley Homeless Connection and its parent organization, the Valley Community Services Board, the local lead in the federally subsidized Continuum of Care system that is designed to end homelessness by coordinating services across multiple sectors.

Above all, it requires someone to sit up and take notice. And for city planners to get out of their information silos.

Data is important, but even more important are the stories that put a human face on an otherwise abstract problem. In that regard, I urge everyone reading this to see a free local  screening of a tremendously evocative 50-minute documentary on the subject of older adults aging into homelessness, ‘No Place to Grow Old.’ You can see the trailer here.

Sponsored by Valley Supportive Housing, ‘No Place to Grow Old’ will be shown Thursday, Oct. 15 at 6:30 p.m. at McCracken Hall, Trinity Episcopal Church in downtown Staunton; and again on Sunday, October 25 at 3 p.m. in the fellowship hall of Central United Methodist Church, also in downtown Staunton.

A cold shoulder for the heat-stricken

(Reading time: 5 minutes)

Been hot lately? If you’re a farmer, you know all about that. Ditto for construction workers, city public works employees, high school kids in the marching band all decked out in their uniforms. But perhaps no group of people is more attuned to changing weather and temperature extremes than those who don’t have a home.

For these folks, where to sleep on any particular night is always an issue, of course. But so is figuring out how to shower and wash clothes, how to protect personal possessions from theft or confiscation, how to take care of relatively minor injuries or illness before they blossom into left-threatening maladies. All those efforts are complicated by extreme heat, such as we’ve been experiencing this summer, but also by extreme cold, snow and ice, as when Staunton was hammered this past winter.

So it’s encouraging, at this summer mid-point, to learn that Staunton’s government, the city’s faith-based community and its social service agencies have finally acknowledged that they have a responsibility to help this most vulnerable segment of our local population. Thanks to the outspoken leadership of several key community leaders and a vigorous fund-raising effort, augmented by a generous allocation of city funds and an outpouring of volunteer support, we can now expect . . . ha-ha-ha! Just kidding. None of that actually happened.

What did happen was very little, and the near-term outlook is for even less than that.

Here’s some of the good stuff. The Valley Mission continues to operate the area’s primary homelessness shelter, supplemented by other organizations providing limited shelter space for women. Trinity Episcopal in downtown Staunton is still serving free lunch each weekday (as does the Mission), thanks to a rotating roster of supporting groups of volunteer cooks and servers. After a fumbling effort last year, a cooling shelter has been open for eight hours each weekday since early July in the basement of Faith Lutheran Church, also in downtown Staunton.

Here’s some not-so-good stuff. Valley Mission continues to sit on a multi-million-dollar windfall it amassed, thanks to a surplus of pandemic funding, with no public indication of how it might use that money to expand its operation. The cooling shelter is scheduled to have its last day Sept. 4, long before daytime highs will be reliably moderate, but not before its volunteer staff dwindles to a fraction of its start-up numbers. The director of the Waynesboro Area Refuge Ministry, which provides overnight shelter in church facilities during the winter months, is stepping down for health reasons—even as church participation in the effort has been declining.

And looming over all of that is the federal government’s attack on social services funding of every description, from SNAP (food stamp) benefits to housing vouchers to Medicaid coverage. Perhaps most egregious, however, may be the Trump administration’s efforts to kick people out of permanent supportive housing and back onto the streets by changing the way the Dept. of House and Urban Development (HUD) grants more than $4 billion to homelessness programs. Although those changes have been enmeshed in months of court challenges and reversals, there still is no clear resolution in sight.

“HUD doesn’t know what’s going on,” said Crystal Stuck, chair of the Valley Homeless Connection (VHC), in a recent conference call of local service providers. “For now, things are going to stay the way they are—but we don’t know what’s coming down the pike.”

Meanwhile, the homelessness situation in our region is only getting worse. Because this past winter’s devastating snow/ice storm essentially torpedoed the annual Point in Time (PIT) census, limiting the count exclusively to sheltered populations, VHC for the first time decided to conduct an additional, summer-time census. Although the statistical analysis of the summer PIT isn’t expected until next month, the raw numbers July 15 were 101 people in shelters in the VHC service area of Augusta, Rockbridge and Highland counties and their cities, as well as 73 people living unsheltered, primarily in tent encampments or cars. That contrasts with 259 people that VHC has on its list of coordinated entry applicants for housing, suggesting that fully a third of the area’s homeless people could not be located.

(By comparison, the local PIT census last year turned up only 156 homeless people, of whom a mere 19 were unsheltered. Then again, the day of that count, Jan. 22, had a high of 22 degrees and a low of 4 degrees in Waynesboro, so once again extreme weather undoubtedly distorted the results.)

According to VHC vice chair Jackson Weatherly, the July PIT counters found “a lot of abandoned encampments” in Staunton and Waynesboro, presumably the result of their occupants being forced to move out. Consequently, he added, “there were many people we were unable to find,” with other homeless people attesting to the existence of new encampments that are staying under the radar. Crunching all the numbers, Weatherly concludes that the SAW region has less than 40% of the shelter space needed for its homeless population.   

Moreover, the shortage is more dire for some groups than for others. The Mission, for example, although a local mainstay, does not admit homeless people who are registered sex offenders and cannot accommodate couples or people with pets. Meanwhile, as both local and national statistics  attest, the homeless population is aging—according to the PIT count from this past winter, 29% of the sheltered population was 55 or older—which creates additional mobility challenges; half of the Mission’s beds are top bunks that may be inaccessible for much of that group.

So the squeeze is on—more homeless people living in more extreme circumstances but with dwindling prospects for more help. Indeed, it’s fair to say that after a whole lot of talking and hand-wringing locally about the homeless, the local people and institutions that ostensibly were coming to their aid are faltering, at best, and dropping away altogether at worst.

 Meanwhile, hard though it may be to envision in mid-August, there is another winter coming.

Kicking the ADU can down the road

(Reading time: 8 minutes)

To better understand why Staunton can’t get a handle on its lack of sufficient affordable housing, consider the June 18 meeting of its Planning Commission. Dominating the 90-minute session was a meandering and inconclusive conversation about a subject the commission has largely ignored, over which it has little control, but about which it is willing to entertain dystopian fantasies. In doing so, it made an inadvertent argument for renaming itself, perhaps as the Reaction Commission. Or the Let’s-First-See-What-Everyone-Else-Is-Doing Commission.

Among Staunton’s most pressing problems is its largely acknowledged if imprecisely documented shortage of housing that local residents making local wages can actually afford. There just isn’t enough of it to go around in the first place, so what’s available is priced out of reach. The obvious solution is to build more housing that is smaller and less expensive, leading to the equally obvious question: why isn’t that happening? And the obvious candidate to answer that question is the provocatively named Planning Commission (there’s also the newly formed Housing Commission, but that bunch is still trying to figure out what it’s doing), which one might think is currently consumed with trying to cut the Gordian knot of failed housing policy. One would be mistaken.

True, there are numerous reasons why Staunton has an insufficient housing supply, reasons that are at work all across the country and most of which are quite out of reach of a mere five Stauntonians meeting once a month, mostly to review rezoning requests. The cost of construction materials has sky-rocketed since the pandemic, the ranks of skilled construction workers have been depleted by Trump’s xenophobic deportation policies, interest rates are high and apparently poised to go higher. Those aren’t things a local planning commission can affect. But there’s also the matter of housing design and density, and that fits squarely within the planning commission’s wheelhouse. It’s also something the commission avoids looking at too closely.

Strange though it might seem, there’s not enough land available for building small homes in Staunton. With an average population density of just over two people per acre, it might appear that Staunton has lots of room for additional housing. But parks and agricultural districts and heavy industry whittle down the amount of land suitable for development. So too with land devoted to roads and parking lots, as well as land that’s too steep or too rocky or subject to flooding. There is land available for sizeable developments, as evidenced by the recently announced 267-home  McIntosh Village, but that’s big money chasing market-rate housing that will be too big and too expensive for empty nesters or service worker paychecks.

But then there’s our fondness for zoning that deliberately spaces homes far apart, allowing few homes per acre and dictating setbacks and minimum lot sizes and maximum lot coverage—our self-imposed limitations on what’s possible, in other words. Not geography or geology, but the very sort of thing that a planning commission concerned about an adequate housing supply for its existing population should be examining.

Just how inadequately it is doing so was on display June 18, when the commission was presented with a proposed amendment of the city zoning code that would clear the way for accessory dwelling units (ADUs) to be built pretty much anywhere Staunton allows housing.  The proposed revision was not something the Planning Commission had solicited. Nor was it sought by the Housing Commission, which has been slow-walking the ADU idea to some future chin-stroking evaluation. It was instead mandated by the Virginia General Assembly, which to its credit got fed up with all the wheel-spinning in the provinces and adopted this past session a bill that overrides local zoning authority.

Most succinctly, the state is mandating that as of July 1, 2027, ADUs are to be permitted by right—that is, without requiring “May I?” special-use review—in all zoning districts throughout the Commonwealth that allow single family use. ADUs are defined as “an attached or detached dwelling” that provides “complete independent living facilities for one or more individuals.” There are restrictions on size and placement, as well as parking and building code requirements, but basically the new law opens the door for homeowners to double their capacity. It could be with a backyard cottage, a basement apartment, a garage with a second-floor apartment. The additional space could be rented out, or it could house an aging parent or adult child. Best of all, the increase in the city’s housing stock will come without requiring any of the new roads, storm water management, water and sewer lines and other infrastructure that come with a new subdivision.

Planning commission reaction? Mixed but generally aghast. Commission member Dale Hansen, fantasizing about slap-dash cabins with hot plates and composting toilets popping up in backyards, said he wants to see some kind of allowance for ADUs “but not getting too crazy, and I don’t know how to regulate crazy,” eliciting sympathetic chuckles from other commissioners. The way the law is written, Hansen complained, “It’s sort of the Wild West—anyone who wants one can get one.” Well, yeah. That’s the idea.

Commission chair Jessica Robinson summarized the commission’s approach to the idea of getting ahead of an issue by asserting, “I don’t want to be a trailblazer.” No fear there—the state has already taken on that mantle—but because Staunton doesn’t have to amend its zoning code before next July, Robinson clearly is hoping to kick the can down the road. “I don’t think it’s impossible that people will start pushing back on this and that at the next General Assembly session it gets put off further?” she suggested, albeit on a questioning note. “And I think we should wait and see and make sure it survives all that.”

There was talk among the commissioners about seeing what zoning amendments other cities are writing—“Let them fail first, before we fail,” Hansen offered helpfully—and a suggestion that perhaps the Housing Commission could provide helpful insights. There was musing about feeling like “deer in the headlights.” None of it grappled with the fact that Virginia now has an explicit law to which Staunton must conform, without a lot of room for creative embellishments or escape clauses, which means there are only so many ways the city’s zoning code can be amended to be in compliance. The rest is wishful thinking.

Unfortunately, it’s not at all clear that the planning commission comprehends just how much the regulatory landscape is shifting beneath its feet. For the state to wade into a zoning issue—one of the few areas of responsibility reserved for localities—is huge. (See also the new state law that gives churches the by-right power to build affordable housing on their property.) At the same time, the commission’s tone-deaf approach to ADUs suggests its members haven’t been paying attention either to the ADU concept or to the housing needs of their neighbors.  ADUs as a relief valve for housing pressures have been around for years—long enough to be a significant part of the conversation at last year’s Virginia Governor’s Housing Conference, as I wrote last fall, and long enough to be discussed by the city’s Housing Strategy Group and in Comprehensive Plan ruminations. The problem locally is that it’s been just that—talk—and little more, as if a bunch of old folks were sitting around discussing the desirability of going to heaven.

The green and (to a lesser extent) the black area in the graph above are prime sources of potential tenants for ADUs and now comprise substantially more than 50% of all households.

Nor will ADUs be the end of it. In addition to having a high percentage of relatively low-wage workers, Staunton has a higher percentage of elderly residents than the national average. It’s sobering, therefore, to learn that the fastest growing group of people entering homelessness are those 55 and older—people increasingly on fixed incomes, often in poor health, who can no longer afford to live in the city in which they were raised or worked or raised their own families. ADUs are not only more appropriately sized for these populations, which don’t need multiple bedrooms or a backyard, but can be built more cheaply and therefore rented for less than single-family homes. But they’re only one possible approach.

Other housing variations that are excluded from permitted uses within current zoning regulations, such as cottage courts, may be next. Expect pressure to grow for allowing single-family home conversions into duplexes or triplexes by right, or for eliminating lot size minimums in established neighborhoods, or for eliminating all parking mandates for housing, thereby freeing up more land for infill development. None of these are novel concepts in the wider world, although they are locally. All should enter into the planning (and housing) commission’s awareness if it wants to avoid future “deer in the headlights” moments, and if it intends to take seriously the “planning” part of its mandate.    

Instead, the commission won’t be meeting again until August, when it’s not clear whether the proposed ADU revisions to the city code it receives will be substantively different from what it’s already seen. The city’s community development planners have been given next to no guidance on what changes to make, beyond a vaguely worded request to “keep refining it.” At some point the commission will have to hold a public hearing on the proposed changes; next April was suggested as a good choice.

No sense in rushing things. Or starting them, for that matter.

Follow the colored-dot road . . .

(Reading time: 17 minutes)

A draft of Staunton’s revised and updated Comprehensive Plan is out for review, following 18 months of data collection, meetings and pulse-taking—including hundreds of colored dots on a wall of easels—and presumably is heading for rapid city council adoption in early June. Public comments are being received until May 26. We should hope there are many.

As plans go, this latest iteration is an improvement over the original, which was adopted July 11, 2019—before Covid and before the post-pandemic explosion in real estate prices, an affordable housing crisis, devastating downtown floods and numerous other shifts in the firmament. That initial “plan” was far more descriptive than prescriptive, more a gazeteer than a road map suitable for navigating two decades. Its conservative approach meant the original plan avoided being derailed by the Covid era, but even on those few occasions when it tried to peer into the future it often missed the mark, as when it projected that Staunton’s population in 2040 would be 25,442—a number the current draft revises upward by 10%.

Predicting the future is tricky business, to be sure. But the 2019 plan also was hindered by its blinkered view of what properly falls within the city government’s scope of responsibilities, a perspective shaped at least as much by philosophy as by financial limitations. The plan’s view of housing, as “primarily a private system that is influenced by factors beyond those controlled by local government,” is perhaps the most egregious example of a hands-off attitude that produced a planning document with obvious blind spots. The result was a soulless slab of prose, devoid of vision or inspiration, suffocated by the expectation that the Staunton of 2040 would be just like Staunton in 2020 only more so.

The new draft, by contrast, takes a more expansive view of the city’s role, which is a welcome change. But it also goes to the opposite emotional extreme, so devoted to “vision” that it often reads like a romantic ode, a fulsome psalm to a city that is welcoming, vibrant, empowering, resilient, inclusive, thriving, harmonious, sustainable . . .  and on and on.  Fair enough—who wouldn’t want to live in a place like that?—but at some point it does become a repetitive blur. The new draft also is big on graphics and states forthrightly it intends to “minimize text,” which may be a nod to shortened attention spans but which undermines its credibility as a planning document. We think, analyze and plan more with words than with images, although images do provide a better complement to the whole “vision” thing.

But whether dry or frothy, both the original and the revision fall short of being either “comprehensive” or of being a “plan.” The update is more aspirational than the original, to be sure, but its attention to detail is erratic and uneven, ranging from the highly specific—even providing exact dollar amounts for specific sidewalk expenditures—to the kind of broad-brush statements of intent with which no one can quibble but with little or no guidance regarding how to get there. The lack of sufficient affordable housing, to offer just one example, is acknowledged as being “a foundational theme that touches nearly all chapters” of the plan, yet the housing section has the least number of proposed “tactics” of any of them, and even those few are wan at best.

Does it matter? On the plan’s own terms, it should. The Comprehensive Plan, according to its introduction, “guides Staunton’s efforts to update local ordinances, justifies city programs and initiatives, helps officials set budget priorities, and directs decisions or development applications.” In other words, the plan defines what’s important and what isn’t. If something isn’t in the plan, it doesn’t exist and stands a good chance of being overlooked. Any evaluation of the plan therefore should pay as much attention to what isn’t there as to what is.

Land Use

In the news business, it’s called burying the lede: starting a story with peripheral details, only getting around to the core concept many paragraphs later.  In the section on land use, the lede is buried in a grey table of “tactics” that makes passing but repeated mention of “updates to the Zoning Ordinance” to solve various problems (infill, residential development in commercial districts, cottage courts, accessory dwelling units, etc.) without any prior narrative introduction of the ordinance, its limitations, or whether the whole thing should be overhauled rather than be subjected to a thousand tweaks and cuts. Instead, the explanatory text preceding the “tactics” (recommendations) is replete with mostly generic drawings of various land uses and how they might be improved, seemingly borrowed from the Cincinnati Urban Design and Architecture Studio, together with concepts like “building to street ratios” that it doesn’t explain. It’s all very colorful, but given the lack of a comprehensive review of the zoning code, mostly unhelpful.

How much more useful would this have been if the plan’s drawings were of actual Staunton city blocks, the streets and existing buildings clearly labeled, together with a vigorous discussion of how Staunton currently assigns land use and how it might do so differently? As it is, an ostensibly comprehensive plan casually presents information that should—but doesn’t—elicit sharp questioning, such as its unquestioned endorsement of reserving nearly a quarter of the city’s land for “heritage farmland.” Should it?  Why? How is it sensible to set aside municipal acreage for cattle grazing when we’re surrounded by the state’s second largest agricultural county?

That’s not to say that the misleadingly labeled “ag-forestal” (much more ag than forest) corner of the city should be turned into suburbs, but that there is no sign that the comprehensive plan even considered alternative uses for the land.  It also plays into repeated nonsense like this statement: “Trends analysis indicates that roughly 86% of Staunton’s land is already developed, meaning future housing growth will rely primarily on reinvestment, infill development, and reuse of existing structures.”  That sounds dire, doesn’t it? But given that 22% of Staunton’s land mass is, as just noted, undeveloped agricultural land, it’s also absurd.

A more accurate—and helpful!—statement would be that “roughly 86% of Staunton’s land is already developed under current zoning constraints,” which opens the door to all kinds of fresh possibilities.  Zoning is something we invented. It’s something we could change. And if we did, it’s amazing how much land would abruptly be available for all sorts of urban designs.

Farmland aside, there are numerous examples of ostensibly “developed” but underutilized land in Staunton. Consider, for example, the commercially zoned dog-leg rectangle between N. Central and Augusta that runs from West Frederick to Pump Street. Covering approximately 7.5 acres, this three-block area is immediately adjacent to the much more densely occupied multi-use downtown area that is generally regarded as an example of enlightened land use. But what do we find here? Five financial institutions, two fast-food restaurants and a store-front church—eight buildings altogether, with a combined footprint a tad over 35,000 square feet, covering just 11% of the land they occupy. As for the other 289,000 square feet of that “developed” land? Mostly asphalt parking lots and driveways.

Imagine if, instead of all those borrowed graphics, the plan had mapped out this three-block expanse and showed how it could be redeveloped for maximum use and return on the dollar. Yes, the land is privately owned. But the private sector, more readily than government, recognizes how it benefits economically from greater density and its synergistic effect on business. What the private sector doesn’t have is the overarching vision and resources to assemble such a transformation. That’s where the comprehensive plan could make a difference.

Blind Spots

The unquestioned acceptance of continuing the ag-forestal land-use designation is symptomatic of a bigger problem within the comprehensive plan: that of failing to see or question what’s right in front of our faces.

Decaying churches

Staunton is chock-a-block with churches, many with congregations that are aging out and increasingly unable to support large sanctuaries. Some are relatively modest, others may include spacious grounds and additional buildings. But like aging parents with a house stuffed full of belongings that no one will know what to do with when they die, too many will pass away without proper dispensation of their assets.  For one example of what that looks like, see the former Bibleway Community Church on West Beverley, vacant for all of this decade and increasingly showing it.

Aging churches can be revitalized or repurposed in various ways, most notably but not solely as affordable housing. But whatever transformation may occur often requires the intervention of an outside agency, such as the city, working from an inventory that assesses which churches can continue to flourish and which ones need hospice care. Most critically, repurposing church properties typically requires someone else to initiate the conversation, since most aging congregations are reluctant to acknowledge they can no longer support their long-established houses of worship. That’s an understandably delicate exchange to have, but it only gets harder the longer it’s postponed.

Even without an inventory of an estimated 76 Staunton churches, there are a couple of obvious places where the comprehensive plan could get the ball rolling. The Marquis Memorial United Methodist Church on West Beverley, for instance, has more than two acres fronting on one of the city’s principal gateways, as well as several vacant and near-vacant buildings. It also has a dwindling congregation and can afford only a part-time pastor. Heating and cooling costs for its large sanctuary are so high that the church frequently holds services in other spaces on the property that have lower ceilings. How much more productively could that property be used?

Or consider Christ United Methodist Church on Churchville Avenue, also a Staunton gateway. A potential candidate for revitalization rather than repurposing, Christ United sits on five acres that present several development possibilities. Some of that land, for example, could be used for housing or a mixed-use development that would generate revenue for the church, thereby creating an income stream that offsets declining financial support from a diminishing congregation. But here, too, it might take creative city outreach to set such a change in motion.

Other iffy assets

Numerous though they are, Staunton’s churches are hardly the only large buildings that are under-utilized or facing obsolescence. Two of the most notable are the vacant and decaying Ingleside Resort, on the north end of town, and the spooky, shuttered sanitarium next to the Frontier Culture Museum. The former apparently is mentioned nowhere in the comprehensive plan. The latter gets a nod in one of the two appendices, in which attendees at an open house suggested the “DeJarnette campus” has development potential. No explanation or context is provided for that description, which would be meaningless for Staunton residents without a good historical grounding, and no attempt is made in the plan to explore the development potential of either property.

An even larger property within the city, widely referenced by the plan as a notable asset while avoiding a direct examination of its precarious outlook, is Mary Baldwin University. The plan does make a brief suggestion that the city should “develop plans for what to do if the worst-case scenarios unfold,” but then fails to describe what those scenarios might be or how the city might respond. That’s unfortunate. The university encompasses 58 acres of prime land and multiple buildings, including dorms that could be repurposed as low-income housing. While closing the campus would be a significant loss to the city, it would open other possibilities to which Staunton should be ready to respond in a timely fashion.

In addition to such major examples, Staunton has numerous vacant buildings whose existence the plan acknowledges but doesn’t address, beyond mentioning that it would be a good idea to inventory them. We’ve known that for years, of course, but for some reason such an inventory has yet to be assembled, which means the city is often flying blind when trying to match unmet needs with unused assets. One example is the city’s recurring failure to find space for a day shelter for the homeless—even though there is, and has been for quite some time, a vacant storefront right next to city hall, as well as several vacant buildings on South Augusta Street, all of which would be more than sufficient for the purpose. And then there’s the former Coca Cola bottling plant at the intersection of Augusta and Churchville streets, which at one point was eyed as a possible brewery but which remains empty year after year.

How is that we have people who need a roof over their heads, and buildings that have roofs but no tenants? And how is it that such an obvious pairing of needs and resources goes unaddressed in the city’s “comprehensive” plan?

Infrastructure

Sewer and stormwater systems are among the infrastructure elements that make it possible for more than 25,000 people to live in close and supportive proximity to each other. But so is the network of water mains and pipes that delivers potable water to every city home and business, and while the comprehensive plan has much to say about storm water it is almost entirely silent about the drinking kind.

That may be the inevitable result of the very visible destruction caused by recent flooding, leading to the plan’s emphasis on storm water management, versus the comparative invisibility of the water that’s being moved underground. On the other hand, last year’s major water-main break came in the middle of the comprehensive plan’s drafting process and should have been top of mind. Instead, the plan says nothing at all about pipes that are now more than a century old, or about a water delivery system that loses more than one in every four gallons that are pumped into it—a rate nearly twice the national average—or about the $40 million to $50 million the city says it will need to fix these problems.

The city shows no sign of knowing where that money will come from. This plan won’t be any help in that regard.

Economic development

To read the comprehensive plan, you might think that the only economic vitality in Staunton is centered on the downtown area, and that the only kind of business the city wants to attract is the kind that plays well with tourists: outdoor recreation, arts and music festivals, restaurants, galleries, theaters, pop-up markets and so on. If the city wants to attract manufacturing of any sort, you wouldn’t know it from this document. Nor would you know what kind of business development the city would like to see along Greenville Avenue or Route 250.

But the plan’s biggest economic oversight is the blind-eye it turns toward Staunton Crossing, which it mentions not at all despite the millions of dollars already poured into that industrial park’s development. That may be because among the park’s targeted industries is a data center, with all the electricity and water consumption issues and controversy that entails—reason enough, perhaps, to just pretend that there’s no “there” there. Unfortunately, that also means there is no consideration in the plan of possible alternatives for the park, such as manufactured housing or solar panels and batteries, which would create many more long-term jobs than a data center and at a far lower social and environmental cost.  

 Ignoring the inevitable

Unlike blind spots, which refer to things the plan simply doesn’t acknowledge, there are several problems or issues the comprehensive plan does see—and then ignores.  

Homelessness

As mentioned above, the new comprehensive plan goes where the old one didn’t by recognizing the centrality of housing to virtually every aspect of the city’s vitality, from economic development to meeting educational needs to community health. And as have other plans that seek community input, the draft plan acknowledges public concern about the consequences of inadequate affordable housing. When plan consultants conducted what they describe as “public intercepts,” housing was the number one concern voiced by the people they encountered, by far. Attendees at an open house highlighted “the lack of focus on vulnerable populations, particularly homelessness, in current plans.”   Vision statements for the city called for “more services for the unhoused.”

So it comes as a surprise that the comprehensive plan presents not even one suggestion for meeting the needs of people who lose their homes, even as it gives pro forma recognition to “the challenges faced by people facing homelessness.” Instead, it deflects. Housing is a “national issue,” the plan explains, presumably as much beyond local control as climate change. “Local efforts are unlikely to ‘solve’ the housing affordability problem.” (Bye-bye, Staunton Housing Commission?)

But failing to “solve” the housing affordability problem, it should go without saying, only guarantees that the number of people who are homeless will continue to grow. Indeed, Alec Gunn, executive director of the Waynesboro Area Relief Ministries, says that demand this past winter for overnight emergency shelter grew 26% over the previous year, even as the number of churches willing to provide such shelter is declining. Efforts to create a day shelter for the homeless have been even more ragged, with a church that was intermittently open for that purpose last summer—a first—declining to do so again this year.

Regarding all this and more having to do with homelessness, the comprehensive plan is silent.

Student population growth

While the plan draft acknowledges that Staunton’s public schools are at or beyond “functional capacity,” its forecast of what that means for the future is tentative at best—even as it cites the possibility of “urgent space management.” “If” current population growth continues, the plan states, “further modular units and long-term facility expansions will be necessary.” But the plan makes no effort to project how much the student population may grow, or in what parts of the city, basically deferring to Staunton City Schools to “assess current conditions and identify future infrastructure, modernization and capacity needs.”

That may be appropriate in jurisdictions where there is greater distance between municipal and pedagogical governance, but the two are intertwined more tightly in Staunton. The city, because of its planning and zoning responsibilities, is in a better position than the school district to assess future growth patterns. At the same time, the city inevitably will be involved in whatever financing is needed for new school buildings, and possibly for expansion or renovation of existing facilities, suggesting that city planning for such developments should be more proactive than the comprehensive plan contemplates.

In closing . . .

To the extent that the revised comprehensive plan is more user-friendly than its predecessor, thanks to more graphics and minimized text, it may pull in more eyeballs and thereby increase public engagement. That’s a good thing. The not-so-good thing is that such overly visual and summarized presentations tend to diminish critical analysis, acting like cotton candy for the brain: long on mouth-feel, but neither filling nor nutritious.

Much of what the comprehensive plan presents is a distillation of the aspirational and critical comments it received from the public in multiple forums—and yes, that’s also a good thing. But most of that feedback was in response to alternatives presented by the plan’s architects (for this feature, do you prefer A or B?), which means public input was largely limited to the subjects and choices it was given. That’s why the plan has so many blind spots, and presumably many more than the few I’ve offered. And when the public was given a more open-ended opportunity to voice concerns, subjects it raised that didn’t fit within the plan’s parameters often would be acknowledged but then ignored.

Making 20-year decisions based on how many colored dots ended up on a series of easels, which was one of the primary methods used to solicit public feedback,  is better than casting a series of animal bones onto a blanket to divine the future. But not that much better.

The housing squeeze, part one

(Reading time: 7 minutes)

To the casual observer, it must seem that we’re in the middle of one heckuva residential building boom—and indeed we are. In Staunton, several dozen apartments have been carved out of what were once commercial buildings, 130 apartments have been built off Middlebrook Avenue, and the planning commission is reviewing an application to build 267 single-family homes in a planned residential development at the end of Richie Boulevard. All that pales when compared to what’s going on in Waynesboro, however, where more than 1,200 new apartments, town homes and single-family homes are being built or have been recently completed, and several hundred more are being discussed.

So what’s with all the local angst about a lack of affordable housing? Aren’t we being swamped by new homes and apartments?

The answer to that lies in the word “affordable.” Yes, there’s a lot of ongoing construction, but all of the examples mentioned above are of homes that will be sold or rented at market rates—and the market is a beast. The house price index in Staunton, for example, rose from 100 in the year 2000 to 185 in 2020, which is to say, home prices rose 85% in that period, or an average of just over 4% a year. But by 2025 the index had jumped to 299.48, zipping along at a brisk 23% average annual increase. Translated into dollars, that boosted the February median home sales price in the Staunton-Augusta-Waynesboro (SAW) area to $330,000, according to local realtor Rick Kane, who’s been tracking these stats for a couple of decades.

Nor is renting a bargain. According to the city’s most recent consolidated plan, prepared as a requirement for receiving federal community development block grants, the fair market rent for a two-bedroom apartment—appropriate for a family with at least one child—in 2024 was $1,149 a month. Apartments.com, meanwhile, currently shows Staunton rents as averaging $$1,151 for a one-bedroom and $1,264 for two bedrooms. (Parenthetically, it’s noteworthy that 45% of all Staunton households with children have only one parent present, according to latest U.S. Census Bureau statistics.)

To put those numbers in perspective, consider that the federal standard for housing affordability is less than 30% of household income. Spending more than that puts you in the “cost-burdened” category, while spending more than 50% pushes you into “severely burdened” territory. To reasonably afford that market-rate two-bedroom apartment, a household would have to be earning $46,000 a year. Homeownership, no surprise, is even pricier: the $330,000 median home sales price will require a six-figure annual income unless the buyer comes in with a downpayment upwards of $66,000—and even then he or she will need an annual income of roughly $80,000.

Now consider this. The median annual wage income for Staunton’s full-time, year-round workforce, according to the most recent U.S. Census report, is $55,023. See the problem?

Unless a household has two wage earners, local homeownership is out of reasonable reach for most. So are rentals for the 1,651 full-time workers in Staunton that the U.S. Census says make less than $35,000 a year. A look at the city’s job openings illustrates how new employees almost invariably will be forced into the rental market: elementary school teachers, for example, start at $53,000, police officers at less than $51,000. The starting wage for a water treatment plant operator is $20 an hour, which works out to affordable rent of just $1,000 a month. Good luck finding such a place.

Many households, of course, have more than one wage-earner, which is why Staunton’s household median income is $11,000 higher than the median for wage-earners. And, of course, there is nothing ironclad about the 30% rule. People routinely pay more than 30% of their income to put a roof over their heads—but that’s the problem. The more someone spends on housing, the less there is for all of life’s other essentials, including food, transportation, health care, clothing and childcare. Small wonder, then, that the 2025 Community Needs Health Assessment prepared by Augusta Health reported that 25.8% of Staunton residents don’t have enough cash on hand to cover a $400 emergency expense.

One of the problems with such statistics is that they paint with a broad brush, glossing over the glaring disparities among various subgroups. This is especially true in any discussion of housing affordability, as illustrated by the graph above. Relatively few people making more than $75,000 a year will have trouble finding affordable housing, not only because they make more money but also because the housing market will have more choices for them. Conversely, those who make less than $30,000 are overwhelmingly cost-burdened, not only because they can’t afford much of a home but because they’ll be lucky to find anything in their price range. As a result, two-thirds of them get pushed into the “severely burdened” category, putting them one misstep away from being homeless.*

(While these bar charts are for the U.S. as a whole, they track the local situation pretty closely. For example, a statistically dated Central Shenandoah Planning District housing study released last year reported that more than 42% of Staunton and Waynesboro renters were cost-burdened, or roughly the percentage for 2019 shown above for “all renter households.”)

All of which raises the question: who’s going to be buying or renting all those new homes that are popping up in our two cities? And the obvious answer is: for the most part, not people who are already here. They can’t afford it.

Some of the new housing in Waynesboro undoubtedly will be snapped up by employees of Northrup-Grumman, which has a new plant that is filling more than 300 new jobs paying an average of $94,000 a year—but an estimated 80% of those jobs require four-year college degrees or more, suggesting many if not most will be filled by employees from elsewhere. But Waynesboro also has become increasingly attractive to a better-paid Charlottesville workforce searching for housing that’s more affordable on this side of Afton Mountain—and once you’ve crossed the Blue Ridge, Staunton is just an additional 20 minutes down the road. So presumably the developers behind all the new construction have looked at all that and concluded there’s a market demand they can meet.

The unmet market—the housing market for median wage earners already here—is another story. As the above analysis should illustrate, there are two sides of the affordable housing equation that can be addressed to make things equal: pay people more money, or build cheaper housing. Neither is about to magically happen, but there is a workaround: subsidize housing builders so they can sell or rent at below-market prices.

Unfortunately, that strikes some people as being, um . . . too much like socialism?

*The statement about homelessness is not hyperbolic. The usefulness of this year’s Point in Time (PIT) count of homeless people in the SAW region was limited because it coincided with the extreme ice storm that paralyzed the region, preventing census takers from seeking out those who were unsheltered. But even surveying just those who were in shelters underscored some troubling trends: 39% of the 157 respondents were homeless for the first time, and 29% were 55 or older. Unemployment and eviction were the two most common reasons they provided to explain their homelessness.


Next up: The housing squeeze, part two. Waynesboro leads the way toward a socialist utopia. Can trouble be far behind?

Housing worries are making us sick

(Reading time: 7 minutes)

Tax season is fully upon us, so it’s only natural for people to grumble about the Internal Revenue Service. But here’s one undeniably good thing for which the taxman can take credit: because of an IRS rule dating back more than a decade, tax-exempt hospitals are required to periodically assess the health needs of the communities they serve. That’s the good news. The bad news, for anyone reading Augusta Health’s report card from last year, is that our health in some key areas has declined steadily since 2016, and a significant reason for that decline is housing affordability issues that weren’t even on the radar a decade ago.

Indeed, the most recent Community Health Needs Assessment (CHNA) provides a sharp contrast to the first in a series dating back to 2013. That freshman effort took a notably upbeat approach by noting that Augusta was the 31st most healthy county in the 20th healthiest state in the country. “Augusta County is living up to its motto ‘Let the ages return to the first golden period,’ referring to a period of simplicity and happiness,” it rhapsodized, in less than scientifically detached fashion. “In general, the Augusta County, Staunton, Waynesboro area outperforms the state averages for health status. Where local results fall at or below those levels, we see an opportunity for combined actions that result in improved community ratings.”

But then, in a prescient turn of phrase, it added: “There are several lifestyle gaps that need to be closed to move Augusta County toward greater overall health.”

Fast forward a dozen years, and last year’s CHNA indicates that those gaps not only were not closed, but that some grew into chasms.  While the 2012-13 assessment ranked chronic disease management, as well as health behaviors (“particularly related to obesity and physical activity”) as its top two health priorities, the 2025 ranking vaults mental health to the top spot. And although physical activity and weight retain their number two ranking, right on their heels as number three is housing, which scarcely registered in the earlier assessment.*  Meanwhile, chronic diseases, led by diabetes, trail behind in importance.

To be sure, the 2013 assessment was significantly more superficial than the reports that started coming out in 2016, when the grunt work was handed over to Professional Research Consultants and a 28-page report metastasized into a document nearly nine times as long. Moreover, the greater detail was complemented by a consistency of format, enabling comparisons across the three-year intervals that followed. The problem is that this consistency also highlights just how much backsliding has occurred.   

AMONG THE ASSESSMENT’S housing-related findings for Staunton (anyone wanting to focus more on Waynesboro or Augusta County can peruse the complete assessment here), nearly a third (32.1%) of residents worried or stressed over their rent or mortgage payments in the previous year—apparently with good reason, as 12.3% reported they had been displaced from their housing within the past two years, and 9.9% said they’d been homeless in that same time period. Another 11.2 % said they were living in unhealthy or unsafe conditions.

For the SAW region as a whole, the incidence of unhealthy or unsafe living conditions jumped significantly from 2019 to 2025, from 9.9% to 14%—but even more sharply for renters, to 19.5%, compared to 10.5% of homeowners. An even wider disparity between renters and homeowners was found in response to the question of housing instability, with 17.8% of renters in the SAW region saying they had to find emergency housing in the previous two years, compared to 4.8% of homeowners. Meanwhile, the overall incidence of housing instability in the SAW region doubled, from 5% in 2016 to 10.2% in 2025.

Homelessness in the SAW region—defined as adults reporting “a time in the past two years when they lived on the street, in a car, or in a temporary shelter”—was zero in 2016, then climbed steadily through each reporting period, to 6.8% in 2025.

The health consequences of being homeless or of living in unsafe housing can be intuited by most people, but less immediately obvious is the toll on mental health taken by persistent anxiety over losing the home one already has. And while there are numerous reasons for depression or suicidal ideation, the parallel growth of deteriorating mental health and of insufficient affordable housing strongly suggests a link. Indeed, as housing stress has grown significantly over the past decade, the area’s mental health has taken a dive:

  • Asked to rate their overall mental health, 21.9% of SAW adults believe it is only “fair” or “poor,” a 150% increase since 2016. Staunton leads the way on that metric, with 27.8% reporting fair or poor mental health.
  • A total of 41.7% of SAW adults (and 50.4% of Stauntonians) say they have had two or more years in their lives when they felt depressed or sad most days. The open-ended nature of that measurement would dilute its significance, were it not for the fact that it is nearly double the 21.8% reading in 2016.
  • More than a third (35.5%) of SAW adults say they have been professionally diagnosed as having a depressive disorder, a 138% increase from the 14.9% reported in 2016. Moreover, that incidence jumps to a whopping 47.1% of Staunton’s adults, which is more than twice the 20.4% incidence for Virginia overall.
  • Local residents aren’t just depressed; 17.2% of SAW adults say they feel that most days are “very” or “extremely” stressful—a percentage also up significantly from the 10.5% recorded in 2016. Staunton leads the pack on this metric as well, with 22.1% reporting they feel stressed out.

Such ailments, alas, afflict some demographic groups far more severely than others, with low income and LGBTQ+ respondents greatly over-represented in all negative ratings—demographic groups that also have less visibility within the larger community, and less political clout with which to address the issues that are making them sick. Nor, once they do get sick, are there adequate mental health and related services to provide the care that’s needed.

The CHNA includes literally scores of comments from local doctors, social services providers, community leaders and others, detailing what they believe are the reasons for this intractable morass. To be blunt, there isn’t much that’s revelatory, although some of the anecdotes—a 35-year-old father, working two jobs to house his family in a motel room, dying from a stress-induced heart attack—get at the human cost of the illness permeating our body politic.  And then there’s the occasional assessment item that further drives the point home, such as the finding that 19.3% of local adults acknowledge they have been “hit, slapped, pushed, kicked or otherwise hurt by an intimate partner.” That rate, too, has doubled since the 9.7% reported in 2016.

The problem with health exams, as all too many physicians know, is that patients will yes them to death—exercise, stop smoking, eat more nutritionally, cut down on the booze, yadda-yadda—and then go blithely on as though no red flags had been raised. So it seems with the 2025 CHNA’s section marked “evaluation of past activities.” Number two on its list of previous strategies was meeting the health care needs of the homeless through a four-pronged approach, all of which were implemented in 2023—and all but one, and then only minimally, going unaddressed in 2024, due to a vacant RN Health Educator position.

Vacant since November 2023, that is, or almost two years prior to the 2025 CHNA’s release.

It’s a near certainty that Augusta Health’s unfilled position is a result of budget constraints, but as with all such cuts, choices reflect priorities. Short-term rewards have a way of biting us in the ass down the road, and a high-salt, high-cholesterol diet almost invariably morphs into diabetes and obesity. But what are you going to do when it’s your doc who’s ignoring sound medical advice?

Meanwhile, it’s clear we have to move beyond discussing the lack of sufficient affordable housing simply in economic terms, or of viewing housing issues through a policy-making lens that bogs down in abstract philosophical differences. The lack of sufficient housing for city residents earning what passes for a living wage locally is a serious health issue every bit as insidious as lead poisoning, seeping into the populace largely unseen and unremarked until it explodes in seemingly inexplicable violence, depression and apathy. The 2025 CHNA waved several red flags. How many more such studies will we need to awaken us to the epidemic that’s underway?


* “Scarcely registered,” indeed. The single mention of housing in the 2013 CHNA was in a graph showing the SAW region’s top three health and community issues, in which “affordable housing” came in at no.21 of 22 issues overall.

Thinking of giving? Think carefully

(Reading time: 9 minutes)

At a time when an increasingly frayed “safety net” is in danger of collapsing altogether, starved of funds and overseen by a vastly hollowed out federal bureaucracy, it’s only to be expected that social service agencies will step up their fund-raising efforts. At our household, for example, we get a plea for donations to the Blue Ridge Area Food Bank at least once a month, to which we respond as we’re able. But the line of those in need cuts across all of life’s essentials, and seems to get only longer, and you have to wonder how it will all end.

One thing about which we should not have to wonder, but which is rarely addressed publicly, is the level of institutional need. Yes, people are hungry, and in need of shelter, and wanting for adequate medical care or school supplies or decent clothing. But are the agencies working to help such people equally needy? How well do they apply the funds they raise, and how accountable and transparent are they with their donors? Do some have more than they need to help their constituents? Or have some squandered the donations they’ve received, as was so blatantly true of the now defunct local United Way a couple of years ago? How many local affiliates of national organizations coast on the latter’s reputations, rather than on their actual accomplishments?

These are tough questions to pose, because they threaten to tarnish institutions seen as local champions of the downtrodden. But the reality is that the pot of community goodwill and financial support is finite, and likely to shrink even as the need keeps growing. Giving money to Agency A means there’s less money to give to Agency B. Yet the few local institutionalized sources of such help—such as Community Development Block Grants, the Community Action Partnership of Staunton, Augusta and Waynesboro (CAPSAW) or the Community Foundation of the Central Blue Ridge—pay scant attention to the financial statements of their grant applicants, showing more concern for how many people their contribution might benefit.  Private contributors, meanwhile, are even less likely to do their homework when responding to the latest tug at their heart strings.

SAW Habitat for Humanity

One prominent example of muddled financial accountability is provided by the SAW Habitat for Humanity, which a couple of years ago was roiled by scandal involving its then-executive director, Lance Barton. Initial accusations of sexual assault by Barton were followed by reporting in the Augusta Free Press of years of Barton’s alleged verbal abuse of staff, temper outbursts, uncomfortable conversations about sex, substance abuse, drunken behavior at work and supposed financial irregularities. By late spring of 2024, Barton was out of a job, Habitat’s board of directors had virtually a complete makeover, and an interim director was brought on to manage the transition until a permanent replacement could be recruited.

That replacement was Brad Bryant, a widely respected local builder, teacher and former Habitat board member who was hired almost ten months ago. To be fair, Bryant inherited a mess—but it’s also fair to question his lack of public progress thus far in setting Habitat’s financial house in order. Although Bryant says the organization recently completed its first financial audit on his watch, its findings have not yet been publicized. Meanwhile, the most recent Form 990 tax return posted on Habitat’s website—the IRS form all non-profit organizations are required to submit to maintain their non-profit status, a form that potential contributors can consult before giving their money—is for the fiscal year that ended June 30, 2022. That was almost four years ago.

More recent Form 990s have been filed with the IRS, but Bryant had not seen them before this week. One was for the fiscal year that ended June 30, 2023. A second, following an apparent decision by the interim executive director to change Habitat’s fiscal year to a calendar year, was filed for the year ending Dec. 31, 2023. Depending on how diligently someone in the public searches for financial accountability, then, there’s been a lack of reporting for more than two years, and possibly quite a bit longer.

Some of that gap may get filled when the recent audit results are published, but even then, the report will be notably deficient in at least one material aspect. Among the financial assets in Habitat’s possession are nearly 300 pieces of poster art that were purchased by the disgraced Barton on a junket to Poland, ostensibly as an investment that could be sold to American collectors at a hefty mark-up. The art was purchased with Habitat funds, on a trip underwritten by Habitat that was rationalized as an unconventional but potentially lucrative fund-raiser. The art now sits in a locked room. It has never been shown to the public, and it has yet to be professionally appraised. Whether it’s a significant if unrealized financial asset, or whether it’s just a lot of worthless paper, the product of Barton’s feverish imagination, remains unknown.

In Bryant’s assessment, any fuss over the Polish art is a tempest in a teapot, much ado about nothing at a time when he’s struggling with more substantive issues to make Habitat “viable again.”  He may be right. He may also be markedly wrong. The point is that a somewhat bizarre aspect of Habitat’s bookkeeping is a black box that the organization doesn’t want anyone looking into. When I asked Habitat’s new chairman of the board, Charles Edmond, for an explanation of the Polish art fiasco, his terse response was to say that “due to ongoing litigation, our attorney has advised us to not talk about this issue at this time.”  Yet as Bryant conceded, there actually isn’t any litigation, just repeated failed attempts at getting the Commonwealth’s Attorney to look at the possibility.

There’s no question that Habitat was left in tatters by its departed executive director, and that restoring its luster—not to mention its effectiveness at actually building affordable housing—is a monumental task. But that task is not made easier in the face of financial inscrutability. Not when organizational viability is dependent on the public’s willingness to open its wallet.

Valley Mission

A diametrically opposite set of circumstances is provided by Valley Mission, which provides long-term shelter and case management for our area’s homeless population. It is perpetually over-subscribed, with a waiting list that can stretch for months, and even though the Mission ostensibly has a six-month window within which its clients are encouraged and worked with to obtain permanent housing, the reality is that a year or more of residency is not unusual. There just isn’t enough affordable housing to meet the need.

It may seem paradoxical, therefore, that the Covid pandemic was very good to the Mission’s financial fortunes. Money poured in from various sources, so even as expenses climbed, revenue far outstripped what was needed, jumping from a more or less normal $1.3 million in 2019 to $2.5 million in 2020 to $3 million in 2021. And although income declined somewhat thereafter, it remained significantly higher than pre-pandemic revenue.

Give the Mission a thumbs-up for showing restraint in the face of this bounty: although expenses have continued to climb every year, they have not outstripped the Mission’s two main sources of regular income, contributions and grants, and the income generated by its thrift stores in Staunton and Waynesboro. The surplus has instead been banked, some in cash and some in investments, where it has been generating an enviable amount of interest income: $103,909 in 2023, for example, and an additional $121,642 in 2024.

All told, then, the Mission ended 2024 (its 2025 financials have not been filed yet) with just a tad less than $3 million in cash, $1.6 million in investments, and a total of $5.4 million in unrestricted assets. To put that in context, the Mission’s total expenses in 2024 were $2.3 million—which is to say, the organization is now sitting on enough liquid assets to operate for two years without a single additional dollar coming in the door. It is, in one sense, functioning like an investment bank, which may not be what potential donors want their contributions to fund.

A possibly bigger problem is that even as it hoards a lot of cash, the Mission continues seeking and receiving funding from the same sources used by other local social service agencies, many of which are also trying to help people meet their housing needs. That includes Waynesboro Area Relief Ministries (WARM), Valley Supportive Housing, New Directions Center, and Renewing Homes of Greater Augusta, all of which operate on a shoestring. Meanwhile, in recent years the Mission has been receiving approximately $7,940 annually from Staunton’s Community Development Block Grant, was awarded $11,500 from the Community Foundation in 2024 and $161,000 in 2023, and in the year ending June 30, 2025, received $36,622 from CAPSAW. That’s all money that would have had a far more meaningful impact elsewhere.

There’s another aspect of the Mission’s growing wealth that is problematic. Not only is the Mission not meeting the full demand for the services it already provides, but there are numerous adjacent needs of the homeless population that remain completely unaddressed.  Among the most prominent, for example, is the lack of a day center in the SAW region to provide shelter and services to people who otherwise are left wandering the streets in search of winter warmth, summer shade and refuge from rain and other extreme weather in all seasons.  There are several reasons why this state of affairs exists, but among the most prominent is a lack of adequate funding.

Providing a day center is not the Mission’s responsibility. On the other hand, it’s not unreasonable to think that perhaps the Mission could expand its efforts to answer an unmet need that is entirely aligned with its core mission.  Perhaps it will.

The Mission’s executive director, Susan Richardson, left open that possibility by asserting that the Mission’s board and leadership “makes financial and strategic decisions based on what we believe is best for Valley Mission and the residents we serve.” So . . . not saying no either to expanding the Mission’s facilities to provide more shelter space, or to filling in other holes in the safety net provided to the same generalized population. But also not saying no to bellying up to the financial water hole frequented by all those other critters in the social services ecosystem, which after all is how the system works.

It’s a jungle out there.

Public housing faces multiple attacks

(Reading time: 5 minutes)

As far as the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is concerned, March came in like a lion.

Starting in late February and continuing into this week, the federal agency responsible for most public housing fired off a volley of proposals guaranteed to make its tenants miserable. The timing, as the economy teeters on the edge of a downturn, affordable housing remains more mythical than real and the war on immigrants continues unabated, couldn’t be more heartless.

The first assault came Feb. 20, when HUD published a proposal to prohibit immigrants who are ineligible for housing assistance from living with family members who are eligible, as is the current policy. The ineligibility list includes immigrants who are otherwise in the U.S. legally, such as immigrants with student visas or those with Temporary Protected Status. Such mixed-status families currently receive prorated housing assistance that covers only the eligible members, which means the family as a whole pays proportionally higher rent than fully eligible families. If adopted, the proposal would force mixed-status families to separate or to leave their homes altogether.

A second shoe dropped just a week later, when HUD took steps to repeal a requirement that public housing agencies and private homeowners accepting vouchers provide their tenants with a 30-day notice before filing for eviction for non-payment of rent. The Feb. 26 announcement was designated an “Interim Final Rule,” which in a ready-fire-aim twist, means that despite a comment period that runs through April, the repeal will go into effect March 30. Although HUD’s notice acknowledges that the 30-day eviction notice “provided tenants with longer runways to undertake remedial actions to become current with their rent,” the agency contends that too many tenants simply took advantage of the additional time to go deeper into arrears.

Besides, HUD added, dropping the 30-day window will improve housing access by “opening up housing opportunities” for people on waitlists for affordable housing. Which fits right in with the Orwellian phrase, “War Is Peace. Freedom Is Slavery. Ignorance Is Strength.”

Consider the graph at the top of this page, which shows that a third of all evicted renters have incomes of less than $30,000 a year. Even at the top of that range, monthly rent of more than $750 pushes a tenant into the “rent burdened” category, which leaves little wiggle room for other necessary living expenses or emergencies. Falling behind on rent by even a month creates a nearly insurmountable financial hurdle for catching up.

But that’s not all. While an estimated 80,000 people would lose their housing assistance because of the mixed-status family rule change, and more than 2 million HUD-assisted households will be impacted by the loss of the 30-day eviction notice, an estimated 3.3 million would lose their rental assistance as a result of a March 2 proposal to impose work requirements and time limits on housing assistance. The estimate, based on an analysis by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, includes 1.7 million children who could lose their homes.

The proposed work requirement, long embraced by political conservatives who fret about welfare queens, would require “work eligible” adults to put in up to 40 hours a week at programs and projects that “address local needs and goals.” Failure to comply with work requirements would be grounds to terminate housing assistance. But potentially even more onerous is the proposal to allow PHAs and housing owners to establish two-year limits on housing assistance for non-elderly, non-disabled families.

All of these proposals are more nuanced than these brief summaries reflect, but the bottom line is that there are more than 10 million people in the United States who have a roof over their heads primarily because of federal rental assistance programs. Most people in HUD-assisted housing who can work do work: in Virginia, 81% of non-disabled people without young children worked in the past year, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition. With the minimum wage in the state set at $12.41 an hour, and Virginia’s fair market rent for a two-bedroom home coming in at $1,749, it should be obvious why subsidized housing is the only way many state residents can have a roof over their heads. Now that’s at increased risk.

Nehemias Velez, executive director of the Staunton Redevelopment and Housing Authority, says he knows of no local families that will be threatened by the proposed mixed-status family proposal. The local effects of the other two proposals, however—not to mention other shots HUD might take in the weeks ahead at the people it ostensibly serves—remain to be seen. But it’s already quite clear that the fragile existence of people depending on federal tax dollars to survive is becoming ever more precarious. And as more of them inevitably get pushed out of their homes, it’s going to be up to municipalities like Staunton to pick up the pieces.

That’s not good. We’re not meeting current demand as it is, with long waiting lists at the housing authority, the Valley Mission and Valley Supportive Housing, so where will the new waves of suddenly homeless people go? How many more emergencies like the one we had in late January will it take before we get serious about developing an adequate supply of affordable housing, as well as providing sufficient transitional emergency shelter spaces to tide people over in the short term? Where is the political leadership we need to start beating the drum on these issues?