Public input is so messy, you know?

(Reading time: 6 minutes)

When publicly-traded companies have bad news they’re forced to share with the public, such as plunging revenues or earnings losses, the time-honored strategy is to release it late on a Friday afternoon. That way, goes the forlorn hope, some of the shock will have dissipated by the time stock trading resumes Monday morning.

That seems to be pretty much the thinking behind Staunton’s promised taking-of-the-pulse for Staunton Crossing. Eight months after the city’s consultant on the massive economic development project, Tim Davey, told city officials that the project’s master plan is overdue for a reevaluation, the people who live in the city finally will be asked to chime in with their thoughts on the subject. Well, sort of—if that’s what you call an online survey consisting largely of multiple-choice questions issued in the holiday-frenzied weeks between Thanksgiving and Christmas. But to me, that reads more like a pro forma Friday-afternoon corporate release of bad tidings.

Not that there’s anything surprising about the move. Davey’s contempt for public input was clearly telegraphed at the October meeting of the city’s Economic Development Authority (EDA), which has oversight of Staunton Crossing’s development, when he revealed unsuspected soothsaying powers by counseling against public information sessions because they wouldn’t yield any new thoughts or insights. An online survey, on the other hand, would be “easy, quick and nimble,” which is consultant-speak for “avoiding messy public emotions and objections.”

The desire to tamp down public input was repeated at yesterday’s brief and sparsely attended EDA meeting (three of seven members were absent), at which Amanda DiMeo, the city’s director of economic development, said there was “nothing to show yet” because the survey is still being drafted. Still, she added, it would consist largely of multiple-choice questions because “we didn’t want to slow up the process too much” by having it “too open” –in other words, by posing open-ended questions that might require fresh analysis of new ideas. Far better, in the interests of “easy, quick and nimble,” to have a fixed universe of acceptable issues and defined responses.

The decision to forego any public hearings, to rely for public feedback solely on an online survey, and to release that survey at precisely the time of year when the public is most distracted from civic issues, is an uncharacteristically cynical posture for Staunton. It is, however, entirely consistent with Tim Davey’s unrelenting advocacy of recruiting a data center for Staunton Crossing. Public support for data centers has plunged all across the country, for numerous and well-known reasons, but Davey has been undeterred and keeps flogging them in one public appearance after another. And make no mistake, data centers are at the center of all this fretting about a plan “update.”

Typically, the pitch has been either “Gee, everyone else is doing data centers, you don’t want to be the only municipality in Virginia to miss out,” or the more blatant dangling of ginormous tax revenues that Staunton could be collecting—as much as $26 million a year if Staunton Crossing were to be carpeted with the things, as Davey observed last month. Not, of course, that he would suggest such a thing. Just saying. . . .

Often obscured by the data center fixation is the original reason behind Staunton Crossing, which was primarily to generate well-paying jobs for a city too disproportionately tilted toward the lesser paying service sector. Aside from the initial construction phase, data centers—which are little more than glorified warehouses—fall remarkably short on that measure, so Davey’s relentless pursuit of that option is at least questionable, and all the more so in the context of an industry that is all too fond of non-disclosure agreements as it pursues new sites.

To get the best bang for the buck—that is, to get the largest number of decent jobs while also maximizing the taxbase—almost certainly calls for recruiting light manufacturing plants, because of their combination of large capital investment and skilled trades. But on that score Davey is remarkably myopic, leaning heavily on pharmaceuticals because that apparently is the latest “it” thing in the state’s economic development, pointing to multi-billion-dollar projects in Albemarle, Richmond and Elkton.

Well, maybe—although it’s worth observing that any development comes with trade-offs, and any chemical-dependent industry has significant environmental implications that deserve a discussion that has yet to take place. But aside from his superficial broaching of the possibilities, Davey’s bigger failing is that he’s so fixated on what others are doing and so obviously uninterested in being progressive or forward-looking. What are the industries of the future, where Staunton has a chance of getting in on the ground floor? What will be the next “it” thing, not this year or next, but in 2030? How can Staunton Crossing take advantage of its location along major road and rail transportation links, which it touts so widely in its promotional material but about which data centers care not one bit?

Instead of feeding the same hackneyed development menu to city planners and officials, how refreshing would it be if Davey and the EDA explored the possibilities of solar or other green industries, from solar panels to batteries to geothermal equipment or wind turbine manufacturing? Or how about picking up on fast-moving changes, both legislatively and technologically, in home manufacturing, with modular housing poised for explosive growth? What could be more fitting, for a part of the state that suffers from a growing shortage of affordable housing, than a manufacturing plant that cranks out wall panels, modular bathrooms and kitchens, and entire housing blocks that could be assembled at a fraction of the cost of site-built homes?

There undoubtedly are numerous other possibilities worthy of discussion, but community discussion clearly is the last thing Davey and the EDA want. The Staunton Crossing plan is nearly a decade old, but talk of “updating” it is window dressing for those who put it together in the first place, and who have locked into its main features. A sincere effort to solicit public input might provide the imagination and vision that is so conspicuously missing at the moment, but that would be too much like work. It wouldn’t be “quick, easy and nimble,” which have become today’s watchwords.

Staunton Crossing dissonance

(Reading time: 4 minutes)

When it comes to its plans for Staunton Crossing, the city is being less than forthright. Coy, even.

Making this evident was session six of Staunton Citizen University, held last week and focused on all things economic. That, of course, meant paying special attention to Staunton Crossing, the hugely ambitious but largely vacant crown jewel in the city’s efforts to gin up economic development.  With its roots dating back to 2009, when the Staunton Economic Development Authority (EDA) shelled out $15 million in a land swap with Western State Hospital, Staunton Crossing now represents an investment of roughly twice that amount. The number of jobs attributed to Staunton Crossing over the past 16 years? Perhaps 200—and some unknown number of those aren’t new to Staunton, since they merely involved a move from one city location to another.

At its best, then, the money sunk into Staunton Crossing currently works out to a per-job cost of approximately $150,000. That’s hardly a bargain, and even less so considering that most of those jobs are on the low end of the wage scale: desk clerks and housekeepers at two hotels, food servers and salesclerks at a handful of fast-food franchises and retail outlets. But to be fair, the Crossing still has another 275 empty acres just waiting for someone to move in. And city officials say that could mean more than 3,000 additional jobs coming to Staunton, resulting in an enormous shift in any cost-benefit analysis, so perhaps it’s still early days when it comes to doing the math.

But that’s where the coyness comes in. What new businesses is the city trying to recruit, and at what additional cost?

Among the six types of industries advertised on Staunton Crossing’s internet pitch is “logistics and transportation,” which sounds an awful lot like a warehouse distribution center. That’s low-hanging fruit, one might imagine, given the Crossing’s touted “easy access to the East Coast and Midwest” because of interstate and railroad proximity. But apparently it’s also forbidden fruit, at least for now. Asked when a large tenant for the Crossing might be recruited, economic development director Amanda DiMeo responded that a warehouse operation could have been landed “yesterday” if that’s all the city was after. Clearly, there’s hope that there are bigger fish to fry.

Which brings us to the second questionable industry on the Crossing wish list: Data Centers & IT. When it comes to recruiting this latest “must have” industry, the EDA marketing push goes all out in playing the environmental hazards card without any apparent irony. Staunton Crossing, declares its website, “is a prime location for data centers due to its low risk of natural disasters. The area is not prone to earthquakes, hurricanes, or severe weather events, which can disrupt data center operations. This provides peace of mind to organizations that rely on the secure and continuous operation of their data centers.”

And that’s not all! Staunton Crossing has an irresistible supply of low-cost and reliable electrical service, according to its website. It has state-of-the-art fiber internet infrastructure. It has “a large pool of highly educated and experienced IT professionals,” which might be expected to raise  quizzical eyebrows among the relatively sparse IT workforce currently in the city. But notably lacking in this recitation of virtues is any mention of the copious amounts of water that data centers require, although the website does give assurances elsewhere that the city can provide 2 million gallons a day.

And that’s a problem.

Two million gallons a day represents the entire output of one of the city’s two major water sources, drawn from the headwaters of the North River in the George Washington National Forest.  The possibility of such an outsized claim on a critical natural resource, in an age of global warming and greater weather instability, including droughts, has not gone down well with community residents with a less boosterish outlook. There have been rumbles of discontent—which may explain a curious comment about the matter by Rodney Rhodes, the city’s director of community development.

Speaking immediately following DiMeo’s presentation, Rhodes led off with the observation that Staunton’s zoning ordinance does not permit data centers. Any attempt to bring in such a center therefore would require that the zoning code be amended—and that, he assured the class, would be “a hard slog.” Not impossible, of course. But hard, so nothing to get excited about.

Nothing to see here!

And yet, why would Staunton keep chasing after a substantial capital investment that its own rules do not permit? Does the question answer itself? A substantial capital investment of the sort represented by a data center wouldn’t provide much in terms of permanent employment, but it would add handsomely to the tax base. And given the many millions already spent on the Crossing with remarkably little return to date, the promise of a big chunk of tax revenue might be expected to transform a hard slog into a greased done-deal.

As I said: coy.